CZOSUG Feedback on OpenSolaris

Not in the plan:

Provide a profile for existing Solaris users. GNU/bash/desktop features are nice for desktop users but may not be good on servers.
Missing guidelines for creating IPS packages. There are no rules.
OpenSolaris is not using IPS in the "eat your own dog food" style. This slows down the development. Many bugs in IPS.
The development of OpenSolaris is way too spontaneous which hurts it's quality.
OpenSolaris is developed by a small group which ignores existing Solaris practices.
Integration of packages via SFW - the requirement to have SVR4 packages for IPS repository. Doesn't scale well and wastes resources.
Decision about including GNU tools - they are not suitable for Solaris because they don't support Solaris specifics.
IPS is too fragile. It is not possible to reinstall a package. No disk format for IPS. Mirroring IPS repositories not supported well. No security updates. No logs, no possibility to provide support for IPS. IPS can break the OS.
Package manager GUI looks like a 10 year old application.
Many man pages are missing.
Broken naming of OpenSolaris (is OpenSolaris a project or is it a distribution?). There's no way to differentiate easily between these two terms.
Broken naming of packages - SUNW-based names, mess in naming of packages.
Error messages from pkg are written to stderr. Provide better error messages.
It is hard to build ONNV and other parts of OpenSolaris.
Provide a possibility to change pool name during installation.

Already in the plan:

Provide a community package repository.
Provide possibility to choose which packages to install during installation (e.g. minimalistic core install for the server).
Missing Sparc support.
NWAM is not reliable.

Labels